Playing Favorites: The Leadership Habit Nobody Admits To with Jeff Conroy
No More Leadership BS
Playing Favorites: The Leadership Habit Nobody Admits To with Jeff Conroy
July 29, 2026
Everyone plays favorites. The question is whether you're doing it by accident or on purpose, and whether your team can tell the difference. This episode breaks down why favoritism quietly wrecks trust, why the "favorite" employee has it harder than you think, and why consistency beats charm every single time.
Playing Favorites: The Leadership Habit Nobody Admits To

Ask any team if everyone plays by the same rules. If the honest answer is no, you've found a leadership problem. This episode digs into favoritism: the thing every manager swears they don't do and every employee swears they can see from a mile away.

Everybody Has One (Yes, Even You)
The crew opens with a hard truth. Leaders play favorites. Not because they're villains, but because they're human. Nobody wakes up planning to pick a favorite employee. It just happens, quietly, through who gets the benefit of the doubt, who gets a second chance, and who gets invited to lunch.

How Favor Turns Into Damage
Favoritism isn't automatically toxic. The hosts make a sharp distinction: a favorite who earned it through reliability and results is different from a favorite who just gets treated better because the boss likes them more. The damage starts the moment inconsistency shows up. Different rules for different people kill trust fast.

The Favorite Isn't Winning Either
One of the sharper points in the episode: being the favorite is its own trap. That person gets stuck between two worlds, expected to stay loyal to leadership while still living among the team. Add pressure from both sides and something eventually cracks.

Consistency Beats Charisma
The hosts land on this again and again. Fairness doesn't mean treating everyone identically. It means holding a consistent standard so nobody's left guessing which version of the boss they'll get today.

The Bottom Line
Favoritism doesn't destroy a team because someone has a favorite. It destroys a team when that favor gets used inconsistently, and everyone starts keeping score.

Tune in for:

Fair leaders aren't perfect. They're just consistent enough that nobody has to guess.


Have questions,  suggestions or just a great story to tell about some Leadership BS you have experienced? Let us know by emailing us T

Today's Featured Coach - 

  • Jeff Conroy - Organizational and Non-profit Expert, Motivational Speaker, Coach -  Executive Leader | Difference Maker for nonprofits in strategic planning, operations, and fundraising and development. Owner/Founder of Conroy Leadership Consulting, LLC. Reach Jeff at jeff@ConroyleadershipConsulting.com or  208-215-6285

The rest of the gang: